What is wrong??
Printed From: Enfield-Rifles.com
Category: Enfields
Forum Name: Enfield Rifles
Forum Description: Anything that has to do with the great Enfield rifles!
URL: http://www.enfield-rifles.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=10115
Printed Date: March 26 2026 at 2:51pm Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 12.07 - https://www.webwizforums.com
Topic: What is wrong??
Posted By: philtno
Subject: What is wrong??
Date Posted: November 17 2019 at 12:30pm
|
Hi guys, I would need and appreciate your experts' advise on what follows: Yesterday I went at the farm i'm shooting at and sent a handful of bullets with my 1943 Longbranch Mk1* at 100 m where i usually use to get grouping around 5-6 cm with the loading I stick with for the last months (37 gn of Varget and Hornady 150 gn .312). This time I repeatedly started to literally spray the bullets all over the target, getting somewhere like 10-12 inches (!!) groups....not just once but three times in a row. OK, there was a bit of wind but, apart from that, all conditions were pretty much the same. What makes me worry and believe it would be unlikely the shooter is that I kept getting good groups with the Mosin...!! So my question to you guys is, apart from making sure the barrel is clean and taken care of, which I always do, what could be the issue? I was thinking about woodwork that might have come loose or something similar but, at first glance, nothing seems to have moved. still have vertical pressure of the barrel at the front sight level, the front sight still not touching the wood... Shall i dismantle it completely? check something in particular?? Thanks for your help ;) Philtno
|
Replies:
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: November 17 2019 at 1:55pm
|
First thing to do is make sure all screws are tight, especially the front trigger guard (main) screw and the butt socket screw. I inadvertently left the main screw loose once and the rifle wouldn’t group.
If no loose screws and barrel is cleaned of all fouling (copper and powder), and you know the load has proven good in the rifle before, I would remove the hand guards and check the barrel pressure on the forend at the muzzle. Slip a piece of paper between forend and barrel at the barrel bearing point and lift the barrel up with a spring scale until the paper will slip.
If you decide to remove the forend, don’t pull the forend down from the muzzle, use a wood block and gently tap down along the upper edge of the forend at the rear supporting the barrel at the muzzle.
|
Posted By: Goosic
Date Posted: November 17 2019 at 2:01pm
|
I am only assuming that the bullets are flat based and not a boattail. The issue might be the muzzle end of the rifling is no longer in contact with the bullets allowing them to roll out and tumble through the air causing your displaced group. Two groove barrels are notorious for losing their rifling at the muzzle and sometimes in the center of the barrel. Check for any bulges in the barrel, check the rifling,and check that the bullets are seated to the specific depth and not set back. You might also consider trying a box of PPU 174grn FMJ's against your handloads and see if they do the same thing as the 150's.
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: November 17 2019 at 2:06pm
|
Yes, muzzle crown wear or damage would cause this. The OP said this load shot good previously, so the crown may have gotten damaged. Inspect with a magnifying glass look for any dings right at the edge of the bore.
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: November 17 2019 at 4:10pm
britrifles wrote:
First thing to do is make sure all screws are tight, especially the front trigger guard (main) screw and the butt socket screw. I inadvertently left the main screw loose once and the rifle wouldn’t group.
If no loose screws and barrel is cleaned of all fouling (copper and powder), and you know the load has proven good in the rifle before, I would remove the hand guards and check the barrel pressure on the forend at the muzzle. Slip a piece of paper between forend and barrel at the barrel bearing point and lift the barrel up with a spring scale until the paper will slip.
If you decide to remove the forend, don’t pull the forend down from the muzzle, use a wood block and gently tap down along the upper edge of the forend at the rear supporting the barrel at the muzzle.
|
Yes, I'll check that. Thanks for the advice. Philtno
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: November 17 2019 at 4:23pm
Goosic wrote:
I am only assuming that the bullets are flat based and not a boattail. The issue might be the muzzle end of the rifling is no longer in contact with the bullets allowing them to roll out and tumble through the air causing your displaced group. Two groove barrels are notorious for losing their rifling at the muzzle and sometimes in the center of the barrel. Check for any bulges in the barrel, check the rifling,and check that the bullets are seated to the specific depth and not set back. You might also consider trying a box of PPU 174grn FMJ's against your handloads and see if they do the same thing as the 150's. |
Yes, those bullets are flat based. I guess if that was a loss of rifling it would have appeared progressively, not that sudden, isn't it?? Regarding bullets seating, the COL was 2.995 - 3.000, basically what Hornady is recommending. But I have to say that some of them were a bit "hard" to push into the chamber, just like if they would be too long, which is strange because I checked the chamber by trying to push an empty case with a bullet set loosely into the chamber to estimate the length available before it touches the rifling and came up with 3.050...I did the same exercise with different bullets i have (174 gn, 150 gn, Speer, Hornady, S&B) and all of them came up much longer than what i'm using (2.995-3.000) while still having the feeling that I have to "push them" into the chamber. I have checked all my cases and made sure they are below or at 2.221 max Now, i'm using the Lee Loader to reload my rounds and the Lee Loader is only neck sizing...could that be part of the issue?? the case being too "deformed'...I have been reloading the same cases about 15 times now. I just ordered some greek milsurp to renew my cases....I'll shoot them to see if they behave the same way. Thanks for your input Goosic. Please let those advices keep coming my way....I want to learn about it. Cheers Philtno
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: November 17 2019 at 4:26pm
britrifles wrote:
Yes, muzzle crown wear or damage would cause this. The OP said this load shot good previously, so the crown may have gotten damaged. Inspect with a magnifying glass look for any dings right at the edge of the bore. |
Yes, I did that and couldn't spot anything wrong...Didn't use a magnifying glass though but I'm kind of very careful with them rifles as I know these are pieces of history i don't want to damage. I'll have a second look tonight. Thanks for the input. Cheers Philtno
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: November 17 2019 at 7:20pm
|
10 to 15 reloads is about when you begin to feel resistance to lock the bolt. Successive firings lengthen the case to the point the case headspaces on the shoulder. You will need to full length size the cases, but don’t bottom the die out on the she!! holder, back it off so that the die will just “bump” the shoulder back a few thousands of an inch. A case length comparator gage works good for this purpose.
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: November 17 2019 at 8:04pm
britrifles wrote:
10 to 15 reloads is about when you begin to feel resistance to lock the bolt. Successive firings lengthen the case to the point the case headspaces on the shoulder. You will need to full length size the cases, but don’t bottom the die out on the she!! holder, back it off so that the die will just “bump” the shoulder back a few thousands of an inch. A case length comparator gage works good for this purpose.
|
Thanks for that Britrifles...  Now, as I mentioned in my earlier post, I don't use any press for reloading, only the Classic Lee Loader...the one where all you need is a rubber mallet and a very tolerant wife (hahaha). I also have trimmed my cases so they are below max length (2.221) so my understanding is that, when you say "full length size the cases" you mean pushing the shoulders back a bit so they don't hit the bottom of the receiver keeping from closing the bolt easily. is that what you mean?? if it is how can I achieve that without a reloading press and the appropriate die?? I guess I can't?? is that correct? Also, side question, could that be the reason for spraying bullets like I did?? Cheers Philtno
|
Posted By: Goosic
Date Posted: November 17 2019 at 8:26pm
|
Before you do anything else,buy a box of commercial ammunition and fire those out of that rifle. If you encounter the same identical issues you are having with your reloaded ammunition, have that barrel carefully inspected for any bulges near the center and any erosion of the rifling from the breech to the muzzle. Those two groove barrels have a habit of losing the rifling from erosion due to corrosive ammunition and excessive firing. The muzzle inwards is where you will see that.
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: November 17 2019 at 9:39pm
Goosic wrote:
Before you do anything else,buy a box of commercial ammunition and fire those out of that rifle. If you encounter the same identical issues you are having with your reloaded ammunition, have that barrel carefully inspected for any bulges near the center and any erosion of the rifling from the breech to the muzzle. Those two groove barrels have a habit of losing the rifling from erosion due to corrosive ammunition and excessive firing. The muzzle inwards is where you will see that. |
Goosic, you seem to insist on the "commercial" rounds I should fire to test if it behaves the same way. Wouldn't you do the same with non-corrosive milsurps, like the greek milsurps I mentioned in my earlier post? From what I receives as information from the gun store I get them from (guncity.com) those are certified non corrosive. Now, you said something that worries me a bit. you said thay "overfiring" it would have the same effects, which I definitely can understand, but what would you consider "overfiring" a No4Mk1*?? I purchased that one in April and have probably shot 7-800 rounds since then, 900 max. Would you consider that as "overfiring it"?? Cheers Philtno
|
Posted By: Goosic
Date Posted: November 18 2019 at 2:47am
|
How many rounds have been through it since 1943 is the question you need to ask yourself. You have a 76 year old rifle that you do not know the exact history of or how many total rounds have been through it in that 76 year time span. I will explain why I would not use milsurp ammunition to test later,but, if you have milsurp ammunition, use it. If it does the same exact thing the handloads are doing then,you need to check the barrel. I have a 1943 Savage No4Mk1*. It shot fine when I first bought it. After a couple hundred rounds through it,the accuracy fell way off and the target looked like someone threw a handful of bullets at it. After checking to make sure all the woodwork and metal bits were snug and tight, I looked at the rifling with a real good bore light. About six inches past the chamber there was a section of rifling missing due to the use of corrosive ammunition and lack of proper cleaning. I also found that the rifling was thinned out to nothing at the muzzle end. The barrel was replaced and it shoots exceptionally well now. I currently have three Longbranch No4Mk1* rifles,one of which will not group any longer because of the same exact issue the Savage had, in the exact same spots in the barrel.
You mention that the Greek milsurp ammunition was "certified" non-corrosive. Did the seller personally breakdown each individual round and remove the primers and then reload each individual round with "certified" non corrosive powder and primers? Commercial ammunition from Herters, Winchester,Remington,and Privi Partizen are all built to tighter tolerances then the milsurp ammunition and will give you a better grouping if,all is well with your rifle. You asked a question in your original post and I have given my answer based off of past experiences with the same exact issue.
|
Posted By: Pukka Bundook
Date Posted: November 18 2019 at 5:50am
|
Goosic, Good advise, but the Greek surplus is known to be non-corrosive and has been known as such for a very long time. It is good stuff as well. I still do not see why a rifle shooting well, should suddenly "go to pot" at the very next outing, so think there is another problem rather than barrel wear. No ideas What exactly, but it might need going through with a fine tooth-comb, so to speak!
|
Posted By: Honkytonk
Date Posted: November 18 2019 at 7:09am
|
I had a similar problem with a Sporter I got in a trade. Would not start shooting good until about 8-10 rounds fired. Then it would group about 3". I would of course take it home and clean it. Next time out, same thing. I ended up bobbing a few inches off the barrel and recrowning. Groups are now about 2" @ 100 yards... as it's a bush gun (I cammoed the stock) I decided not to clean the bore until the end of the shooting season.
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: November 18 2019 at 7:18am
|
The use of corrosive primers will do no harm as long as you clean the bore immediately after shooting. Hot water with a mop works best for this, then dry patches, powder solvent, dry patches and light oil. If you live in a very dry environment, you might get away without cleaning for a while, but if you don't clean out the primer salts, it WILL corrode the bore, showing up as pitting. When it gets bad enough (and it doesn't take long), the bullet will get damaged by the rough surface on the lands and accuracy will degrade as copper fouling will quickly build up. The complete erosion of barrel rifling forward of the chamber is typical of cordite loaded service ammunition (Mk 7 as opposed to Mk 7z). Cordite burns hotter than NC powder, and will burn the throat away. Accuracy life with cordite is on the order of a few thousand rounds.
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: November 18 2019 at 7:22am
Pukka Bundook wrote:
Goosic, Good advise, but the Greek surplus is known to be non-corrosive and has been known as such for a very long time. It is good stuff as well. I still do not see why a rifle shooting well, should suddenly "go to pot" at the very next outing, so think there is another problem rather than barrel wear. No ideas What exactly, but it might need going through with a fine tooth-comb, so to speak! |
I agree with Richard here, the description indicated that last time the rifle shot, it grouped well with the same ammunition. Certainly no harm in trying commercial ammunition to rule out a problem with the load that might have occurred. Give the barrel a good cleaning, preferably with a solvent that will remove copper such as Boretec Eliminator or Sweets 7.62.
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: November 18 2019 at 8:05am
philtno wrote:
britrifles wrote:
10 to 15 reloads is about when you begin to feel resistance to lock the bolt. Successive firings lengthen the case to the point the case headspaces on the shoulder. You will need to full length size the cases, but don’t bottom the die out on the she!! holder, back it off so that the die will just “bump” the shoulder back a few thousands of an inch. A case length comparator gage works good for this purpose.
|
Thanks for that Britrifles...  Now, as I mentioned in my earlier post, I don't use any press for reloading, only the Classic Lee Loader...the one where all you need is a rubber mallet and a very tolerant wife (hahaha). I also have trimmed my cases so they are below max length (2.221) so my understanding is that, when you say "full length size the cases" you mean pushing the shoulders back a bit so they don't hit the bottom of the receiver keeping from closing the bolt easily. is that what you mean?? if it is how can I achieve that without a reloading press and the appropriate die?? I guess I can't?? is that correct? Also, side question, could that be the reason for spraying bullets like I did?? Cheers Philtno
|
I'm not sure about the Classic Lee loader, if the die only neck sizes, then you likely have the problem I described. The cases have stretched such that the shoulder on the case is now bottoming out in the chamber and you can't completely lock the bolt (this is what I mean by the case "headspacing on the shoulder", it should headspace on the rim). You need a Full Length sizing die, which requires a reloading press (I don't know if there is a version of the Lee Loader die that full length sizes the case). The full length die will re-form the fired cases back to the dimensions of the unfired brass and will allow easy chambering. Most .303 chambers are fairly long regarding position of the shoulder. The shoulder on the case typically blows forward on initial firing. If you set up the full length sizing die by screwing it all the way down to touch the she!! holder, it will drive the shoulder of the case back to it's original dimension significantly work hardening the brass. You won't get many reloads this way. If you back the die out of the press a bit (half a turn perhaps), just so that the shoulder on the case is bumped back (shortened) a bit, you will minimize the cold working and extend brass life. The object is to set up the die so that the shoulder is pushed back only a few thousands of an inch.
|
Posted By: Shamu
Date Posted: November 18 2019 at 8:51am
|
The Lee Whack a Mole is neck sizing ONLY. There just isn't the leverage available to full length resize. I have both full length & neck sizing dies for my press, but I do notice with neck sizing only the last fraction of an inch is harder, probably because of the shoulder problem mentioned. Its a known fact that neck sized cases will need to be full length resized eventually. That's why I went with "Partial Full Length Resizing", with a full length die baked off just enough to give minimum clearance at the shoulder. I'd try one box of PPU factory, or new XHP, what we're looking for here is if an unfired, non resized case behaves the same. Try either, just to see what happens. Hey its reloadable too, whichever you use, so you get 20 more pieces of brass! How many cases do you have in total that may need full length resizing?
------------- Don't shoot till you see the whites of their thighs. (Unofficial motto of the Royal Air Force)
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: November 18 2019 at 11:28am
|
Thank you all for your advice and comments. I should have mentioned that, since I bought that rifle, I have been really cautious cleaning it thoroughly including with copper remover right after shooting and the bore is like a mirror with clear rifling. Of course, I'm far from being an expert but, for what i can see, it doesn't look much different from what it was when I first got it.
Shamu, in total, I have 100 cases made of 20 PPU and 80 XHP (greek milsurp). I got the PPU first and reloaded them a couple of times before buying the HXP. In total I might have reloaded them between 10-15 times. I trimmed them manually a some point when i saw that the case length were far beyond the recommended case length. Cheers Philtno
|
Posted By: Shamu
Date Posted: November 18 2019 at 11:40am
|
at 10~15 reloads they are getting near the end of their life. Things like work hardening & metal flow have probably begun to take their toll. Have you done a paperclip test (bend the tip of a paperclip & run it up & down inside the case). If they "grab" anywhere your brass is getting ready to separate. Like the top ones in these sectioned cases) I'm thinking old, tired brass may be a factor here. You've done really well to get them lasting that long, many get 3~4 loads at best.
------------- Don't shoot till you see the whites of their thighs. (Unofficial motto of the Royal Air Force)
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: November 18 2019 at 11:50am
Shamu wrote:
at 10~15 reloads they are getting near the end of their life.Things like work hardening & metal flow have probably begun to take their toll. Have you done a paperclip test (bend the tip of a paperclip & run it up & down inside the case. If they "grab" anywhere your brass is getting ready to separate. Like the top ones in these sectioned cases) I'm thinking old, tired brass may be a factor here. You've done really well to get them lasting that long, many get 3~4 loads at best.
|
Thanks for the illustration, Shamu. I'll try that...although I am pretty sure that those old cases are actually past the average life. Over the batch that I bought (talking about the HXP), I only had 4 that I had to remove from the pack, two with neck splitting, one with some kind of longitudinal crack along the case and one that went brittle underneath a patch of corrosion.
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: November 18 2019 at 1:55pm
|
I've no kidding loaded my cases 30+ times until signs of case head separation occur. You will see a light line forming circumferentially on the case exterior where the thinning occurs, about 1/2 an inch up from the rim. At that point, it's probably been reloaded a few too many times. There are variables here that come into play, but with decent brass (like HXP and PPU) you should be able to get 30+ reloads. Neck size only until you feel resistance to fully locking the bolt, then bump the shoulder back, and then go back to neck sizing until it again feel resistance to locking the bolt. You must always check for case length after sizing (even after neck sizing), the brass will gradually grow and cause the same problem to locking the bolt as the case mouth will contact the end of the chamber. I don't know what this might do to chamber pressure, but I would avoid it. 2.222 inches is max length. I set my calipers to 2.222 and run every case thru them. Ones that don't go thru get trimmed back to 2.215. If you don't shoot much, then throwing out brass after 10 or 15 reloads is fine, but I want to get all the life out of the brass I can. Yes, I've gone too far and had a few case heads separate (the LE action safely vents the gas from the port on the left side of the receiver), but I have learned to recognize the impending separation and toss the case at that point. Inspect them before every reload.
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: November 19 2019 at 12:13am
|
OK, I checked my cases and the shoulder is basically 25-35 thousands taller than recommended....for all of them, PPU and HXP. Now I need to find someone who has a press and the 303 resizing die in the area.....bring him/her a pack of Stella Artois and make friends :D
|
Posted By: Pukka Bundook
Date Posted: November 19 2019 at 6:00am
|
The Forstner case trimmer shouldn't be too expensive, Phil. If I spelled it right, and if they're still in business!
|
Posted By: Stanforth
Date Posted: November 19 2019 at 8:55am
philtno wrote:
OK, I checked my cases and the shoulder is basically 25-35 thousands taller than recommended....for all of them, PPU and HXP.Now I need to find someone who has a press and the 303 resizing die in the area.....bring him/her a pack of Stella Artois and make friends :D |
This may be a bit radical but... Have you thought of buying one? Believe it or not, my favorite press is the Lee hand press. I have 5 presses and I haven't used any of the others for years. You don't need a special room it can be used anywhere including on the range.
------------- Life.. a sexually transmitted condition that is invariably fatal.
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: November 19 2019 at 10:25am
|
Yup, I pretty much use only my Lee Classic press. Heavy duty for 1 1/4 inch dies, used with an insert that came with the press for 7/8 inch dies. I needed the larger press for Snider and MH reloading. Back to the OP, I'm experiencing a similar issue with a sudden loss of accuracy on my Dad's No. 4(T). It was shooting great last month, 10 shot groups at 100 yards in the 1.5 to 2.0 inch range. Even had a five shot group under an inch. Now, it's throwing out fliers 5 inches off the group!! I had previously found the solder joint had broken on the front scope mount pad, but I fixed that with new screws and red Loctite, it hasn't moved. After the repair, it shot great for the next 150 rounds, then suddenly went bad. I removed the scope, shot it with the Mk 1 service sight, still bad. I removed the forend, the only problem I found was the end was cracked vertically along the grain in the trigger slot area. I wouldn't think that would be the problem. Very frustrating.
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: November 19 2019 at 11:51am
Stanforth wrote:
philtno wrote:
OK, I checked my cases and the shoulder is basically 25-35 thousands taller than recommended....for all of them, PPU and HXP.Now I need to find someone who has a press and the 303 resizing die in the area.....bring him/her a pack of Stella Artois and make friends :D |
This may be a bit radical but... Have you thought of buying one? Believe it or not, my favorite press is the Lee hand press. I have 5 presses and I haven't used any of the others for years. You don't need a special room it can be used anywhere including on the range. |
Well, that was not my original intention as I want to stay simple/cheap/easy with as less moving part as possible (i'm a musician and my fingers are important, you know....although I have to admit that having to bang the Lee Loader with a hammer does really help with my ears....but 35 years of playing R'n'R have had serious impact on them already  ) but I guess I will have to make that step...one day....sooner or later, I guess. There are some second hand press available on the market...
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: November 19 2019 at 11:53am
Pukka Bundook wrote:
The Forstner case trimmer shouldn't be too expensive, Phil. If I spelled it right, and if they're still in business! |
Pukka, I already have something to trim my cases...as I understand, what I need is bumping the shoulders back a tad...well a few tens of thousands. Cheers Philtno
|
Posted By: Shamu
Date Posted: November 19 2019 at 3:20pm
|
You're a bit far or I'd offer to do it for you, but the shipping is probably more than the cost of the brass!
------------- Don't shoot till you see the whites of their thighs. (Unofficial motto of the Royal Air Force)
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: November 20 2019 at 12:06pm
Shamu wrote:
You're a bit far or I'd offer to do it for you, but the shipping is probably more than the cost of the brass! |
That's very nice from you, Shamu. I really appreciate  In the meantime I have had a chat with the local gun shop owner and he gave me the details of the previous owner of the same gun shop who is now retired but who, apparently, could help me with that... Thanks again for the offer.. Regards
Philtno
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: December 13 2019 at 9:53pm
Stanforth wrote:
This may be a bit radical but... Have you thought of buying one? Believe it or not, my favorite press is the Lee hand press. I have 5 presses and I haven't used any of the others for years. You don't need a special room it can be used anywhere including on the range. |
Hi Stanforth, Actually I'm wondering if that wouldn't be an easy solution.... my concern is that I might have to push hard to resize the brasses to an acceptable level. Is it really doable with .303....and eventually 7.62x54R. The problem is that I don't want to invest too much without being sure that it would help me somehow, and I currently don't really have the space at the moment to set up a press. We're looking at moving to another house but that is just a "wish" at this stage. Lee Hand press is relatively cheap and I can find decent dices for a good price as well, I think... Please advise  Cheers Philtno
|
Posted By: Stanforth
Date Posted: December 14 2019 at 5:22am
|
I use the Lee Hand press for the following calibres. .295X23 Morris.. 7X57 Mauser.. .43 Egyptian Remington... .303 British... 7.62 Nato... 50/70 Govt.... 6.5mm Swedish...
Apart from the usual loading progress it also handles medium case forming.
------------- Life.. a sexually transmitted condition that is invariably fatal.
|
Posted By: Goosic
Date Posted: December 14 2019 at 5:44am
|
philtno. On the barrel knox,(the flat spot). Is there a stamp that looks like an asterisk ? Also,is there an R stamped on the flat spot of the barrel ?
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: December 14 2019 at 1:35pm
Goosic wrote:
philtno. On the barrel knox,(the flat spot). Is there a stamp that looks like an asterisk ? Also,is there an R stamped on the flat spot of the barrel ?
|
Hi Goosic,I guess I will have to remove the front guard to check that??? P.
|
Posted By: Goosic
Date Posted: December 14 2019 at 1:47pm
|
Yes. Remove the front handguard and look on top of the barrel Knox form and look for and asterisk and a R
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: December 17 2019 at 4:07pm
Goosic wrote:
Yes. Remove the front handguard and look on top of the barrel Knox form and look for and asterisk and a R |
Hi Goosic, I haven't got the time to do that yet but I will have a look. What is that asterisk and that R supposed to mean?? Cheers Philtno
|
Posted By: Goosic
Date Posted: December 17 2019 at 4:18pm
|
During a FTR, factory thorough repair. If rust is found in the barrel they would stamp an * and or an R,or both on the barrel Knox form. Does the rifle still widely disperse the bullets around the target?
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: December 17 2019 at 5:36pm
Goosic wrote:
During a FTR, factory thorough repair. If rust is found in the barrel they would stamp an * and or an R,or both on the barrel Knox form. Does the rifle still widely disperse the bullets around the target? |
The barrel is very shiny with no pitting (it's cleaned thoroughly and checked after each shooting) so I doubt i will find those marks, but I will check. I haven't been able to shoot it for approximately a month as i broke the extractor's spring some weeks ago...and it took some weeks to find some new ones....Canuk was actually very nice sending me some which were received on the exact same day i received those I ordered from the UK. I just replaced the spring and haven't had the chance to fire it. I put the old cases on the side for now (will probably try to full length resize them, just to see if I can reuse them) and will shoot some HXP I recently bought... we'll see how it goes and I'll let you guys know  Cheers
Philtno
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: December 19 2019 at 8:08pm
Goosic wrote:
philtno. On the barrel knox,(the flat spot). Is there a stamp that looks like an asterisk ? Also,is there an R stamped on the flat spot of the barrel ?
|
Hi Goosic, No there is no such marks... Cheers Philtno
|
Posted By: Goosic
Date Posted: December 19 2019 at 8:42pm
|
No asterisk style stamp or an R or both,great. Now,you indicate that you have a very shiny bore. Do you have a bore gauge you can run through the length of the barrel to check for any spots in the rifling that might be deteriorated that might let the bullet momentarily lose its grip on the rifling and allow said bullet to disperse itself the way you describe in the your very first question in this thread? I stated in an earlier post that I had a rifle do what yours did. I was shooting reloads and made an assumption that it was my handloads, until i ran factory ammunition through it and those did the same thing. I took another rifle and ran both my reloads and factory rounds through that rifle and nothing substantial happened, groups were fine. It wasn't until I was able to examine the bore and the rifling from the breech to the muzzle that I discovered the corrosion just past the chamber and the loss of rifling at the muzzle. Visually with a bore light,I had an excellent shiny bore. It was not until I was able to view the rifling with a bore scope that I found the corrosion and the loss of grooves throughout the length of the barrel. Do you have another Enfield or can you borrow one a friend may have to run comparison tests against to positively eliminate the possibility that it might be a worn out barrel?
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: December 19 2019 at 8:54pm
|
Hi Goosic, No I don't have any bore gauge and no other Enfield, unfortunately. I hear what you say but would that happen that suddenly?? All my shots of the previous shooting session were all within normal Enfield accuracy boundaries.... I would even say that I had pretty good results, to the point that I really believed I had found my perfect combination powder/projectile/loading. The only thing that changed from that session to the next one was that my cases had one more load and that they started to be difficult to chamber and to eject.....which led to my questions about the resizing issue.
|
Posted By: Goosic
Date Posted: December 19 2019 at 9:42pm
|
I hear what you say but would that happen that suddenly??
It did not happen suddenly. You are not the first person to handle or fire that weapon either. The 42 stamped on your barrel is a date and 77-78 years has elapsed between the time that date was struck to today. The possibility that thousands of rounds of ammunition, corrosive and non-corrosive,reloads and factory have been fired through that barrel in the span of three quarters of a century is very likely then not. When I made a suggestion to you to test factory made ammunition against your reloads to examine if the grouping changed or not,I was by no means condemning your chosen handloads. The factory rounds simply give you a baseline to compare against. If the factory ammunition produces the same results your handloads produced you will have eliminated one issue you think might be the cause. Someone here knows this and can answer correctly. I remember reading that the Enfield rifle barrel started losing its accuracy after 7700-9500 rounds passed through it.
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: December 20 2019 at 1:05am
Thanks for that, Goosic I guess I will have the answer soon.....it's Christmas Break so I will have plenty of time to go shooting.I have HXP to shoot and I guess it will give its verdict...at least eliminating one of the possible causes. Yep, really looking forward to it... 
|
Posted By: The Armourer
Date Posted: December 20 2019 at 3:10am
Goosic wrote:
Someone here knows this and can answer correctly. I remember reading that the Enfield rifle barrel started losing its accuracy after 7700-9500 rounds passed through it. |
The Armourers Manual :
Life of a rifle barrel. A rifle barrel should fire 5000 to 6000 rounds at least. This depends, however, on the care exercised when cleaning after firing. Amount of wear or variation in rifle barrels is ascertained by means of gauges mentioned below :- .301”, .307”, .308”, .310” and No2 Lead. Gauge plug.301” should run through the barrel to show freedom from bends, metallic and other fouling. A rod plug (screwed at end) is used to test with gauges plug.
The undermentioned gauges are not issued to armourers with units, but are available in R.E.M.E. workshops :- Plug .307” should run through the barrel Plug .308” should not enter muzzle ¼” Plug .310” should not enter breech ¼” Plug lead No2 should not enter chamber ½”
And elsewhere :
2) Mark 7 .303-in S.A.A. has a cordite load and a flat based bullet. He same applies to .303-in tracer and .303-in AP
Mark 8Z .303-in S.A.A has a neonate load and a streamline based bullet. Trial firings have proved that these two types of ammunition do not wear the barrel in the same manner. Barrels which have been used for Mk.7 or .303-in Tracer or AP become inaccurate much sooner when Mk8Z is used in them, than barrels in which Mk8z only has been employed.
3) One of the advantages of Mk8Z ammunition is that the barrel maintains accuracy and elevation until the actual moment of collapse. No indication of approaching barrel failure is given when Mk8Z ammunition is used. Accuracy is liable to break down very suddenly and the barrel becomes dangerous for use for overhead fire in the later stages of its life. To ensure the safety of our own troops during overhead fire by medium machine guns, the life of a .303 Vickers gun barrel using Mk8Z S.A.A has, therefore been fixed at 10,000 rounds (or 40 belts). This figure is well within the number of rounds successfully completed by the earliest failure of barrels firing an endurance and accuracy test under conditions of excessively rapid rates of fire. If, however, even a few rounds of cordite loaded S.A.A. are fired, the Mk8Z accuracy life drops considerably.
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: December 20 2019 at 3:20am
That's very good and interesting info, Alan  Thanks for that Philtno
|
Posted By: Goosic
Date Posted: December 20 2019 at 5:52am
|
This is where I keep insisting that you may actually have a very worn barrel. The Armourer gave a textbook answer of 5000-6000 rounds. If you give the average age of your rifle 77 years old and then add 100 rounds fired through it every year since its inception. There is a high possibility that 7700 rounds have been through it. 1700-2700 rounds more then the service life described from the armour's textbook supplied answer.
|
Posted By: Pukka Bundook
Date Posted: December 20 2019 at 6:24am
|
Goosic, Worn barrel or no, no-one here as yet has a Good reason for the rifle shooting well on one outing and Not on the very next outing. Barrel wear does not show up like this in shooting results. A worn barrel will start to taper off, not suddenly decide to shoot badly Between outings.
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: December 20 2019 at 6:34am
|
Richard, that's exactly what I was thinking. Phil, can you tell us about how many rounds you have put thru it with good results? I'm at a loss as to what may have suddenly happened. Could the bedding have gotten damaged (in the draws particularly), have you had the forend off prior to the accuracy problem surfacing? Barrel life is tricky to estimate. Even gaging won't necessarily tell you if it will shoot good. It still may be worth trying some factory rounds if you have them, although it's not likely to be a problem with your reloads.
|
Posted By: The Armourer
Date Posted: December 20 2019 at 8:22am
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: December 20 2019 at 1:40pm
|
Interesting. I wonder if its the MK VIII bullet that will suddenly loose accuracy as a barrel wears. I'm having trouble understanding the physics of why a barrel accuracy suddenly "breaks down". Perhaps that bullet shape may suddenly loose stability in the bore whereas a flat based bullet with a longer bearing surface may remain stable in a worn bore. I estimate I've shot about 5,000 rounds thru my No. 4, about 95% of that with 174 gr HPBT bullet. If the accuracy suddenly goes to crap, this will be my first thought.
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: December 20 2019 at 2:08pm
|
The other interesting bit of info shown is the MK 7 and 8 ammunition acceptable accuracy was an 8 inch Figure of Merit (FOM) at 600 yards. The FOM is the mean radial dispersion of a 20 round group (i.e. the average distance of all the rounds to the group center). The extreme spread (distance across the two widest shots) is at minimum, twice this value (i.e. 16 inches). At best, that is about 2.5 MOA, but more than likely, it's substantially more than that for a 20 round group, perhaps even twice this value (i.e. 5 MOA). It all depends on how the rounds dispersed and how far from center were the two widest fliers. This is the acceptance standard, so the ammunition is not supposed to be worse than this. For the Canadian MK 7z ball ammo I have shot, extreme spread of 10 rounds was in the 2 to 3 MOA range out of my No. 4 Mk 1/3 Fulton prepped match rifle which had a new 5 groove BSA barrel at the time. Post WW II Mk 7z produced for matches shot under 2 MOA.
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: December 21 2019 at 1:19am
britrifles wrote:
Richard, that's exactly what I was thinking. Phil, can you tell us about how many rounds you have put thru it with good results? I'm at a loss as to what may have suddenly happened. Could the bedding have gotten damaged (in the draws particularly), have you had the forend off prior to the accuracy problem surfacing? Barrel life is tricky to estimate. Even gaging won't necessarily tell you if it will shoot good. It still may be worth trying some factory rounds if you have them, although it's not likely to be a problem with your reloads. |
Hi Britrifles, I can say, without any exaggeration, that the grouping I achieved over the last 3-4 shooting sessions were very good. Before that, I was mostly experimenting with projectiles, powder, loadings and bullet seating which means results were varying a bit more....some were not working well and some other leading me to the direction I finally took with that specific loading I was using for the last shooting....and that was working very well. I would say that, since I kind of found my ideal loading, I might have put something like 250 rounds with that loading. The woodwork has not been played with since the initial check up when I got the rifle. The only thing that changed was that I attached a sling and the fact that most of the rounds were very hard to chamber.... I might well be a combination of factors... I had planned to go shooting tomorrow but it has been cancelled so it will be next week. I have some HXP to shoot. For my own information, I took twenty of them rounds from the pack I bought and measured the weight of the bullets and the powder loading (I have no clue of what kind of powder it is. All I can say is that it's very fine spherical powder)...some slight variations but globally pretty consistent so the shooting should be pretty consistent as well, I supposed  Yesterday I took those cases that I previously put aside, those that were causing some chamber issue and tried to chamber them again.....over the 120 I had, 20 only were chambering normally, all the others I had to push hard to chamber them.....some I didn't even tried to push them completely, being concerned that they would get stuck in the chamber. I truly hope that the issue was due to the rounds and not the barrel...if no changes, I'll bring the rifle to the gunsmith for a thorough inspection. I'm not qualified nor knowledgeable enough to do that myself 
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: December 21 2019 at 4:43am
|
Phil,
Have you measured the length of your cases? Each firing causes them to stretch slightly which will eventually result in the case mouth contacting the end of the chamber and get jammed between the chamber walls and the bullet. This shows up as resistance to closing the bolt. The Sierra Reloading manual says this will give rise to dangerous pressure levels. This in turn will cause wild shooting. The max length is 2.222 inches.
I also suggest giving the chamber a good cleaning with a bronze chamber brush. I clean the chamber completely after each shooting. Wrap a powder solvent soaked patch around the brush and turn in the chamber. A chamber cleaning rod like Deweys brass rod is very useful for this. Before firing, remove all traces of solvent and oil by wrapping a patch around the brush and apply brake cleaner to the patch. Get it squeaky clean. This not only ensures reliable feeding/chamber in for fire formed cases, it reduces thrust load on the bolt.
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: December 21 2019 at 6:52am
|
I re-read one of your earlier posts and you said you have already checked all your cases for length. Are you using calipers for this? If so, that’s not likely the cause of inaccuracy.
I don’t know what the effect is on accuracy with cases that have grown headspace and get difficult to close the bolt. This would put some slight preloading of the action. I’ve not noticed a problem when the bolt shows some light resistance. At that point, I’ve always FL sized the cases. If you can get the cases FL sized and test fire again, and see if you still have the problem. But you will have to check case length after FL sizing, they will likely lengthen by .010 to .015 inches.
|
Posted By: Goosic
Date Posted: December 21 2019 at 7:37am
|
I suggested using factory loaded ammunition due to it already being sized to proper length . If the bolt has to be forced to close or the bullet disperses widely, then you need to start examining the barrel more closely...
|
Posted By: Honkytonk
Date Posted: December 21 2019 at 8:09am
|
Question. If cartridge brass is correct length, and bolt is stiff to close, could it be an oversized bolt end? Like excess headspace but in reverse?
|
Posted By: Shamu
Date Posted: December 21 2019 at 9:38am
|
Its possible, but unlikely. Its far more likely to be the shoulder being too far forward though.
There's a gauge for that also, the
GO = 0.064"
------------- Don't shoot till you see the whites of their thighs. (Unofficial motto of the Royal Air Force)
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: December 21 2019 at 2:59pm
|
Right, I think we have established the cases need to have the shoulder bumped back with a FL sizing die. I think Phil said he has loaded the cases 15 times or more. If he did not have resistance in closing the bolt when the cases were new, it’s not a short headspace problem.
Gossic may be right, but I’m hoping not as it means a barrel replacement. Still, I’m suspicious given the sudden loss of accuracy shooting flat based bullets.
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: December 21 2019 at 3:29pm
Wait and see, guys....wait and see  I can't give you more details for now but will surely do so once I will have had that opportunity to shoot those HXP. And I just ordered a hand press with the .303 (and 7.62x54R) dies to F/L size the cases. I also have what it needs to trim them back to recommended case length. Cheers Philtno
|
Posted By: shiloh
Date Posted: December 21 2019 at 3:36pm
Read this post a few times now and all advise is good but the thing(s) id reconmend is get a single stage lee press and 303 dies fl size your brass and trim to 2.22 Run some reloads and also maybe fire some nos surplus or ppu174gr rounds and see what happen. Without full length sizing to bump back the shoulderd you're to have accuracy issues, even with a worn barrel you get consitancy, not great groups, but consitance. Just my 2cents. ;)
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: December 21 2019 at 3:44pm
|
OK Phil, get busy! I think you are on the right track. Waiting on a range report!
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: December 22 2019 at 12:42am
britrifles wrote:
Waiting on a range report! |
After all that rumble I created with my post, you bet I will  Cheers Philtno
|
Posted By: shiloh
Date Posted: December 22 2019 at 4:54am
|
54R dies will push the 303 shoulder .21" farther down and change the shoulder angle, there is @ 2deg diff between the two, this should make it fit better in the chamber.
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: December 22 2019 at 5:24am
|
yes, but the 7.62x54R body is larger in diameter. The .303 die should be able to push the shoulder back more than enough. I would start with the .303 die backed out 1/2 turn or more and adjust as required until the bolt will close on the empty sized case with no resistance. This minimizes cold working of the brass.
|
Posted By: shiloh
Date Posted: December 22 2019 at 5:59am
britrifles wrote:
yes, but the 7.62x54R body is larger in diameter. The .303 die should be able to push the shoulder back more than enough. I would start with the .303 die backed out 1/2 turn or more and adjust as required until the bolt will close on the empty sized case with no resistance. This minimizes cold working of the brass.
|
+1
resize 303 with 303 dies for proper sizing specs.
|
Posted By: Goosic
Date Posted: December 22 2019 at 7:24am
|
The main body of your original post states that. Yesterday I went at the farm i'm shooting at and sent a handful of bullets with my 1943 Longbranch Mk1* at 100 m where i usually use to get grouping around 5-6 cm with the loading I stick with for the last months (37 gn of Varget and Hornady 150 gn .312). This time I repeatedly started to literally spray the bullets all over the target, getting somewhere like 10-12 inches (!!) groups....not just once but three times in a row.
You have made an assumption now that it is your reloads that are causing this issue without comparison tests with factory ammunition,including the Greek surplus ammunition you have. Why not? Your Long Branch has a two groove barrel that is 77 plus years old that has countless round through it and is notorious for extreme muzzle end wear on the rifling causing a keyhole effect when firing through a worn barrel. Regardless of how shiny a bore looks,unless it is professionally gauged,that's all you have,a shiny barrel that looks okay. Your new project is to use 7.62x54R reloading dies on your .303 cartridges instead of using the proper .303 dies just to push the shoulder down an extra few thousands of an inch when the factory standard is all that is needed. Why? Your bolt is hard to close down when your reloads are used as you have stated. Have you tried to check that against a factory round? In all my 34 years of reloading the .303B I have only encountered one occasion when the groupings went he!! in a handbasket for no apparent reason and that was when we had discovered that the 1943 No4MkI* Savage's rifling was worn out. It looked shiny though. Without having the proper inspection done to the barrel with the proper gauges you are never going to know with any amount of certainty what is causing this issue and assuming it is not operator error because the Mosin still shoots good is still an assumption. Your focus on rectifying the reloaded cartridge case issue is very commendable. But why are you circumventing the possible worn barrel issue? Also. What is reasoning for not wanting to check a couple dozen of your handloads against the same amount of factory rounds to see if the issue is still there or if it goes away using factory rounds? Cheers Michael...
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: December 22 2019 at 8:17am
|
I do think it’s worth shooting some factory loads.
I also noted the load is a bit light in the pants. This can be a factor with bores that are on the large side. The .303 starting load published by Hodgdon for Varget with a 150 gr bullet is 39 grains. Along with factory loads, I would try 40 gr Varget with a 174 gr bullet. I’ve not had good success with Varget and light loads. H4895 is a better choice if you want to shoot light loads.
Gaging or slugging the barrel would be good information to have. But keep in mind that large bores have been know to still shoot good with the right bullet and load.
|
Posted By: Goosic
Date Posted: December 22 2019 at 9:21am
|
I have been dinking around with subsonic loads for the 7.62x51/.308. No extreme bullet dispersion on the target as of yet. The .303 rounds I use are the 174grn BTHP Hornady and the Woodleigh 215grn monster. The only difference there is in bullet drop at 100 yards and beyond with the 215grn ogive. My Hornady book gives a min 33.0 to a max of 40.8 of VARGET when in use with a 150grn bullet. The min of 31.6 and a max of 39.1 of VARGET for the 174 grn FMJBT and the RN. The OP states that he was using 37.0 with a 150 grn bullet. Not that it matters. The issue is with the spraying of bullets all over the target now. Phil. What where you shooting through the rifle prior to this incident? What bullet weight and powder charge? Not that it matters as well. britrifles, you of all people here knows that a 125 150 174 and 180 grn bullet performs differently in bullet drop at a given distance. The same can be said for the general grouping,to a degree. A handload if properly sized,trimmed and loaded to the same standards as a factory round should perform just like the factory counterparts, agreed? The belief here is that there is no way that the accuracy JUST went to crap,its because of a reloading issue. This issue did not JUST happen. It took 77 plus years,countless amounts of ammunition going through it,with an unknown amount of previous owners that fired those countless amounts.Not to mention if the rifle saw actual combat or not. What would or should be the first thing to check for when you are shooting a vintage rifle and the accuracy goes to $!#t on you. Mine would be to check the rifling by a competent gunsmith.
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: December 22 2019 at 1:36pm
|
Yes, as a few very knowledgeable armorers have told me if all else is good and the rifle still won’t shoot, it’s probably the barrel. A barrel inspection and gaging will tell you if the barrel is within specs. Shooting will tell you if the barrel has lost accuracy.
I struggled for a few years with a M1 that had a brand new barrel when I bought it from the CMP. After a few hundred rounds, accuracy went to crap. Sometimes it would cluster groups nicely, then start double grouping, or throwing one or two rounds wide out of the group. Think of a 8 MOA group, very ugly.
After a few thousand rounds, I gaged the barrel, .3000 gage ran thru, .3005 would not pass. Rifling looked perfect in a bore scope. I removed the barrel and returned it to criterion. They gaged and inspected it and confirmed my previous findings (.3002 bore, very little wear), they said it looked excellent and well maintained. Then they sawed it in half lengthwise and found that the throat had been reamed off center, the depth of the grooves were asymmetric in the throat. Likely a bad headspace reamer and subsequent firing just made it worse. The new barrel fixed the problem.
Since Enfield barrels in new condition are hard to come by, it may be worth one last shot (pun intended) to check factory rounds and perhaps another bullet. But I do agree, poor shooting is rarely a problem with correctly and carefully assembled handloads.
Hodgdon Varget (ADI version of 4064) seems to have a particular issue with light loads, many shooters have experienced it including myself. Inconsistent velocity and even ignition problems in loads with moderate airspace, especially in colder weather. Hodgdon recommends not reducing the loads below their published minimums. I use their load tables, other published data shows reduced max load. I have chrono’ed my 40.0 grain load with the 174 SMK and it’s right on with Hodgdon data. For info, Hodgdon is the distributor in the US, the powder is made by ADI and Hodgdon publishes their reloading data.
|
Posted By: Shamu
Date Posted: December 22 2019 at 5:37pm
|
I'd just like to clarify. Are you suggesting using the 7.26X54R dies to push .303 shoulders, or is it you have both calibers & so have ordered a press & both die sets to use on the respective cases?
------------- Don't shoot till you see the whites of their thighs. (Unofficial motto of the Royal Air Force)
|
Posted By: Goosic
Date Posted: December 22 2019 at 5:43pm
|
If you read his latest post line for line the answer is yes.
Wait and see, guys....wait and see  I can't give you more details for now but will surely do so once I will have had that opportunity to shoot those HXP. And I just ordered a hand press with the .303 (and 7.62x54R) dies to F/L size THE CASES. I also have what it needs to trim them back to recommended case length. Cheers Philtno
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: December 22 2019 at 8:16pm
|
Hold your horses guys......please hold on!!! There is a bit of mis-communication here I think!! I never said I wanted to use 54R dies on my .303 or inversely.....At this stage I just ordered .303 dies, 54R dies and a hand press.....I haven't got the stuff yet!! Goosic, I really appreciate your comments and your questions "why", and I will certainly keep that into consideration but at this stage, I haven't fired my 303 again yet since that very day I noticed the spreading!! I broken the spring the day before the very next shooting session.....and I just replaced it last week. And I haven't said I intended to disregard the potential barrel issue....I just haven't done anything yet!! And, I basically agree on everything you guys would say, but please give time to be in a position to implement your advice and to see if that brings anything new. Also, please consider that you guys have different opinions and advice to give me. I'm certainly not about to favour or disregard any of them.....just give me the opportunity to soak my mind with them and make my decision on which way I'm keen to try first.  I feel a bit harassed by so many questions on why I have done this or haven't done that....Keep in mind that I don't have your experience for sure, I'm new to that (the only experience in shooting and maintaining a gun was 35 years ago when I was doing my military service)...but I'm learning from everything you guys say....just give me time to go at my own pace, make my own experiments, eventually, and share that with you when it's done... Again, I really appreciate all your advices. Thank you very much for that, it's really great help.... but too much information at once, too many questions or too many different options at once is a bit pressuring me and makes me believe I'm in deep $h!1{.... I'll let you know when I have new elements to this very issue....maybe the whole issue will be solved?? Who knows?? I want to be and stay positive  Cheers Philtno
|
Posted By: Goosic
Date Posted: December 22 2019 at 9:32pm
|
I truly apologize if my questions and comments have pressured you in any way and have made you feel harassed.
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: December 22 2019 at 9:39pm
Goosic wrote:
I truly apologize if my questions and comments have pressured you in any way and have made you feel harassed. |
No worries.... I really appreciate your good advices and experience  . I guess I'm just much slower in my reasoning and my action taking to solve my issue :) The good side of it is that I'm learning....which is good!! Cheers Philtno
|
Posted By: Shamu
Date Posted: December 23 2019 at 6:47am
|
Please don't feel harassed, thats not the intent I assure you. The problem with troubleshooting on-line is that the knowledge is remote & the hands are on site, so there has to be a lot of too & fro & asking of questions because we don't have the item in hand. Take your time & let us know how it turns out.
------------- Don't shoot till you see the whites of their thighs. (Unofficial motto of the Royal Air Force)
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: December 23 2019 at 2:09pm
|
Sham is quite right.
My earlier encouragement was not intended to pressure you Phil, this is all supposed to be fun.
I think we can all step back for a bit and let Phil digest this and plan out the next steps. We will patiently await the next report.
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: December 30 2019 at 1:59pm
Hi guys,First off, Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to every one  Then, I finally had the chance to shoot the No4 again with some non-reloaded ammo i.e. HXP milsurps. Remember that, during the last shooting session, I was suddenly "spraying" pills all over the place while previously having relatively good results with reloaded ammo, basically consistently reaching very acceptable results at 105m (meaning 2"-3" groupings with sometimes even better than that). The question arose that it might have been the barrel, the woodwork, the bedding, the ammo, the loads...my main concern being that my reloaded ammo were just fitting the chamber with some steady push to close the bolt. Well, yesterday I went shooting some 1968-1976 HXP (pretty mixed years of production) and managed to shoot 1.5" at 50m and 3.5" at 105m....despite one split case and one pierced primer (the rest was in pretty good condition for 45-50 years old ammo). I also tried again some old reloaded ammo (some left over hard to chamber rounds from that previous terrible shooting session) and guess what.....all over the place!! I also shot some rounds loaded with 37 gn of H4895 and 150 Hornady (.312) projectiles using the few cases I was left with and which were still chambering relatively smoothly and managed to get a 3-5cm groupings at 50m, meaning 1.2-2" grouping which is similar to those I was used to get before. In the meantime, I received the hand press I ordered and have started to full length resize those old cases and trim them to standard which was far from being luxury as some of them were up to 2.235".....whereas the recommended max is 2.221. However, the previous discussion and the various considerations addressed here made me conscious that, at one stage, I will have to have the No4 checked and eventually "serviced" by a gunsmith anyway... But for now, smile is back on my face  and I'm currently reading The 2012 Complete Book on Lee Enfield Accurizing by Roger Wadham  Cheers Philtno
|
Posted By: pisco
Date Posted: December 30 2019 at 2:57pm
|
hi you will get things back on track don’t give up
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: December 30 2019 at 3:28pm
|
Good progress Phil. Your results with the HXP are about as good as it gets. Let us know how the FL sized reloads work out.
It is normal that the cases will lengthen by .010 inches or more after FL sizing. I typically trim FL sized cases to about 2.22 inches as they will actually shorten on the first firing.
|
Posted By: philtno
Date Posted: December 31 2019 at 12:44am
britrifles wrote:
I typically trim FL sized cases to about 2.22 inches as they will actually shorten on the first firing. |
The case shorten on the first fire?? I thought it is the opposite....that firing the round was actually "blowing" the brass to the size of the chamber and, given that the LE chamber is rather generous, it was expanding it rather than shortening it?? Can you explain?? Philtno
|
Posted By: Goosic
Date Posted: December 31 2019 at 4:16am
Due to the generous chamber area, when the factory or full length resized cartridge is fired it will expand outwards to fill in the voids of that generous chamber area causing the case to shorten itself to an extent and thus "fireforming" itself to be used in that rifle and that rifle only. Afterwhich your precision hand held Lee Loader will neck size only your brass. Your reloading manual gives you a maximum case length of 2.222" but, it should also give you a "trim to length" of 2.212" to allow for the brass to flow and be reworked after every subsequent firing. You mentioned that the Greek surplus ammunition worked out great with no issues as opposed to your old reloads which went everywhere. You also mention that you tried some new reloads and the groups were slightly on par with the Greek stuff. The 174grn HXP bullet is longer and has more surface area to make contact with the rifling giving better trajectories as opposed to the smaller 150 grain bullet you are currently using,especially with a two groove barrel which will more often then not give you a wider dispersal of shots due to the lack of surface area of the smaller ogive,especially if that two groove barrel is worn to any extent.
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: December 31 2019 at 5:46am
|
Goosic explained it correctly. It is only the first firing of a FL sized case that will shorten (new factory brass is FL sized). If you were to again FL size the case after the first firing, it will lengthen. That’s why you always must check length and trim after sizing.
Neck sizing helps to minimize this case length stretching/shortening cycle and prolongs case life. But when you encounter the problem you did with difficulty closing the bolt, you must FL resize.
It is well worth the time and effort to experiment with different bullets. The 2 groove barrel performed well with the .303 Mk 7 service bullet, it was flat based and had a long bearing surface for its mass. Like any other barrel, bore and groove diameters will influence the bullet stability and accuracy.
It would be an interesting exercise to get our members to slug their bores and measure the land and groove diameters to see if there is a correlation with accuracy. Pin gages can also be used to get the bore diameter, they are inexpensive typically available in .0005 inch increments. The two No. 4 .303 rifles I have are both 5 groove:
Long Branch Mk 1/3 with BSA barrel: bore .3035, groove .314 Savage Mk 1/3 with FAZ barrel: bore .3025, groove .314
Both these rifles shoot the Sierra (.311) and Hornady (.312) 174 gr boat tail match bullets under 2 MOA.
It’s taken at least 5000 rounds for my BSA barreled LB to wear the lands from .3030+ to .3035. When I got the rifle, it was a new barrel, the .30300 Parker Hale gage would pass with a slight drag, the .30325 would not enter the throat. Now the .30350 gage will pass with a slight drag (.3040- pin gage will not enter the muzzle or throat). So that’s at least .00025 inch wear over 5000 rounds. Not much.
|
Posted By: Honkytonk
Date Posted: December 31 2019 at 5:57am
|
Before I started buying Privi brass, I used what was available at the local gun shop. Usually Winchester. I ran them thru the FL die because on visual inspection, lots of case mouths were squished in a bit. I just ordered 100 new Privi. Do most members run new brass thru the die or am I over thinking? Thanks.
|
Posted By: britrifles
Date Posted: December 31 2019 at 6:07am
|
HT, at minimum, you should neck size to round up the necks and check case length. Trimming to square the case mouth and get a consistent case length may also be worthwhile. I typically do not run new brass thru a FL die.
|
Posted By: Honkytonk
Date Posted: December 31 2019 at 6:27am
|
Good advise. That will be my new protocol for new brass, thanks!
|
Posted By: Shamu
Date Posted: December 31 2019 at 8:08am
|
From your latest results I think there's something "bad" in the load that all over the place. When I say "bad" me an not tuned to that exact rifle. If it were a gun related problem I'd expect to see it consistently now it started but this seems to come & go depending on the load. It can happen you just get a load where not all the components work together well. One possibility is barrel harmonics. When you fire your barrel vibrates like a plucked guitar string several waves all at the same time. A good load (sometimes for that exact rifle) will release the bullet from the muzzle when the bore is fully deflected in a particular direction. I know it sounds odd but the bore is actually stationary at the point, briefly, so the bullet always leaves in the exact same direction. If you now have a load the vibrates differently it might easily release when the barrel is whipping past neutral, so its moving at (comparatively) high angular speed.
------------- Don't shoot till you see the whites of their thighs. (Unofficial motto of the Royal Air Force)
|
|