Print Page | Close Window

"Crimes against Collectables"

Printed From: Enfield-Rifles.com
Category: Enfields
Forum Name: Enfield Rifles
Forum Description: Anything that has to do with the great Enfield rifles!
URL: http://www.enfield-rifles.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=7116
Printed Date: March 26 2026 at 5:57pm
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 12.07 - https://www.webwizforums.com


Topic: "Crimes against Collectables"
Posted By: MaxP
Subject: "Crimes against Collectables"
Date Posted: October 12 2014 at 12:17am
Hats off to those who have the patience and the love of these rifles to do ground up restoration jobs. I also collected parts and still do if I come across a bargain, and like to see the bits go to good builds.

Just going on from a few comments from Bear43 and Homer with regard to the stripping and selling of collectables. Yes, there are a lot of bits out there, and where they came from is anyone's guess most of the time. But.... Here's a crime I found out about a year or so after it happened....

For starters, here is a Pattern14 No1 .22trainer.



 It was an 1898 Sparkbrook MLE Mk1, then in 1905 it became a Sht LE ConDII, then in 1914/15 only 427 were converted to the Pattern14 No1 .22 Trainer. Yep... it's pretty rare. Real traceable history! A .22 Trainer with all the characteristics of a Sht LE Mk1.

Some enterprising gent here in Aust happened upon a dozen of these trainers a while back. Here's a couple of pics....




Yep, he stripped out and cut up about 12 out of a total production of 427 rifles to sell the parts off to people restoring a couple of the 360,000 odd Sht LE Mk1's made. The irony of it all, the "restored" rifles (most of which would have needed foreends, handguards and nosecaps) will never be any more than bitsa's anyway because of the unmatched parts, and might never be worth the sum of the parts!




Replies:
Posted By: muffett.2008
Date Posted: October 12 2014 at 1:43am
There should be a law against parting outCensored


Posted By: Jon287
Date Posted: October 12 2014 at 3:17am
CryCensored

-------------
Now is the time for all good men to come to the aid of their planet!!


Posted By: paddyofurniture
Date Posted: October 12 2014 at 7:06am
I think they should cut him up and sell him for parts.

No Enfields where harmed by this post.

-------------
Always looking for military manuals, Dodge M37 items,books on Berlin Germany, old atlases ( before 1946) , military maps of Scotland. English and Canadian gun parts.


Posted By: A square 10
Date Posted: October 12 2014 at 12:09pm
dittos what has been said , what a shame - i need one of those for my collection 


Posted By: W.R.Buchanan
Date Posted: October 12 2014 at 12:21pm
This is a situation where a guy didn't know what he had in the first place.  I doubt he would have parted these guns out had he known their value.
 
That's why you do research on what you've got before you go stupid on it!
 
When it comes to which way you should go with any antique restoration,,, and I am talking Guns, Jeeps, Old Cars or Boats and list goes on,,, research as to what you have actually got is a key function in your preparation..
 
I have done all of the above and the two main considerations must always be,,, Actual rarity of the item, and condition. Super rare goes back stock unless irreparable modification has been done.  Resto mod is next, and full custom follows. Note: I did not say "hack it up and make A POS out of it."  There must be improvement made or your just ruining something for no good reason.
 
Lots of times stupid kids are given priceless treasures by their grand parents, and then proceed to try to turn them into what they think is cool. This ultimately shows lack of parenting! , as any kid who is not taught what is cool by his parents usually grows up to be patently stupid and we've got plenty of them already,,, Mainly cuz their parents were stupid too?
 
I once saw a kid who had been given an essentially NIB 1953 CJ3B (with <5000 miles on it in 2005!!!) and turn it into a beat up Rock Crawler!  This Jeep needed tires and a battery and had been driven to town a couple of miles away every week for 52 years for groceries.  It was garage kept, taken care of, and nearly perfect!  It was also the most pristine example of a CJ3B that anyone had ever seen at the time and was valued at nearly $50K! After he got done with it, and ran it thru a few rock trails it was essentially worthless. Took less than 6 months for him to work his magic on this poor Jeep. After he showed his accomplishments on a CJ3B website, he was chastised by so many people, that I think he locked himself in the basement and is still there as far as I know.
 
 I have also seen virtually every other level of usage for those Jeeps from leaving them completely stock and running them until they are completely used up, to 100 point Military Restos (M606) to full custom jeeps that anyone would be proud to own and drive.  Look at all the Hotrods out there, some are complete restos some are Resto mods.  Whatever is appropriate for a given vehicle is the name of the game.
 
Guns are more of the same,  but with guns, condition is my primary factor.  Most of the guns I see or get ahold of were made in the Millions. The likelihood of finding a Real Rare One is slim since there were so many made, and collectors got to all the really good ones along time ago.  So I research what I've got and then decide what to do with it.  I'm not a big fan of Military style battle rifles. but if a  pristine one came my way I certainly wouldn't be hacking it up to make a Sporter out of it. It has more value as an original. Ultimately end value is the biggest consideration we all have to consider.
 
However another example would be the #4 Mk1 I bought a couple of months ago.  The metal was all there and in good shape. The wood had been "sporterized" and looked bad.  I had no intention of returning it to full wood and in fact had the picture of an L42A1 or L39A1 in mind from the start,  so that's what I went for.
 
 I wanted a shooter, and that was my purpose for buying the thing in the first place. Mind you I have made no permanent modification to the gun and it could easily be returned to milspec just by replacing the wood. But they made millions of these and there are plenty out there for us to play with, in fact I could buy three more like it today if I chose.
 
Now if the barrel had been cut off it's fate would have been sealed by the previous owner and there would be no speculation on what to do with it. it's a Sporter.
 
I wanted something else, so I went the Target Rifle route,,, but at the end of the day it is MY gun to do with as I see fit, and this also applies to everyone else's guns ( and Jeeps) as well.
 
here's what I started with,,, photo 100463695_zpsff5da2e2.jpg
 
here's what I ended up with,,, photo 027bde75-f71c-4fe1-be1e-5f7333580194_zps2e17cb60.jpg
 
There has to be improvement you are wasting your time and money.
 
I think this one is worth more than the $200 I paid for it?
 
Randy
 
 
 
 
 
 


-------------
It's not how well you do what you know how to do,,, It's how well you do what you DON'T know how to do.


Posted By: Zed
Date Posted: October 13 2014 at 3:56am
Some people automatically think that a large calibre rifle is more valuable than a .22. Unfortunately that's not tha case and it sounds like the value of the remaining 415 just went up a notch!


-------------
It's nice to be important, but it's more important to be nice!


Posted By: MaxP
Date Posted: October 13 2014 at 4:13am
I too started out my Enfield obsession with a sporter. It was a very cheap but effective hunting rifle in a .303 wildcat calibre. At the time I was eighteen with a good job but a passion for fast cars meant my shooting was done on a shoestring budget. I couldn't afford a proper hunting or target rifle. I was never under any illusions about it. It would always be a chopped up milsurp, worth less than the sum of the parts due to the amount of them available in the same condition. Yes, Australians probably chopped up more Lee Enfields per head of population than any other country in the world. We are still tripping over them all over the place with pricetags of around $150 and no buyers for them. With a $300 scope they might pull $200, such is the market here.



Having caught the bug when I bought a No5 a year or so later, and then researching and restoring a 1905 BSA Mk1*** (over two years in the making). Every single (original) rifle I have bought since has been appreciating in value faster than superannuation. I still have the sporter, although re barreled back to .303 with a Lithgow H tube, and has seen a few different incarnations (currently in transformation again) it still shoots sub MOA no matter what I do to it.

Several of my standard rifles that I have used shoot MOA too. I only use one load in all of them, and that replicates MkVII ball, just like they were designed and tuned to use. Unless there is a serious issue with the barrel, they would all perform well with sub sonic ammo with minimal load tuning. That was proven to me by a mate who shot a well worn 1917 BSA with cast pills and cut one hole groups all day. I asked him about bedding, he laughed. He took off the nosecap and handguards and the group didn't change. He then took the foreend off and put another five rounds through the same hole. No science in that.

I spent many hours studying the bedding techniques of the masters of target shooting in this country from the forties and fifties. I have started from scratch with a bubba rifle and unfitted woodwork and after many dozens of careful hours work, been rewarded with exceptional results with MkVII loads like they were building their competition rifles for over half a century ago. No bedding compounds, no epoxies, just metal on wood... wood carefully removed a few thou at a time and checked time after time.
There is where the true art lies. I can see no art in gouging an extra 1/4 inch out, pouring in some commercial compound and clamping the lot together. To me the idea seems an almost sacrilegious end to a proud part of our history. The rest is just window dressing, so bears no influence on the outcome other than the time and cost incurred to do it.
As far as being a means to an end, the modifying of a milsurp for anything more than shooting a modified class in service rifle comp would have to be because of a passion, because common sense says a second hand sporting rifle will cost about the same as modifying a milsurp and usually be a better suited tool for the job and hold it's value better!

This is just my experience and opinions. I play with modern weapons for 37 1/2 hours a week (with a generous super plan and holidays). They hold some interest for me. Just a few weeks ago I was ringing a steel fig 11... 6/6 at a lasered distance of 1050m! But my passion is for oiled wood and blued steel.
 At the end of the day I think we all agree that rare collectables should be preserved... usually only already bubba'd rifles should be fiddled with further... and we support those who have the passion for faithful restorations and the thirst for knowledge.





Posted By: Homer
Date Posted: October 13 2014 at 4:28am
I had three of those 427 converted rifles. All three are sold and the money for them plus a pafker hiscock magazine that went with one of them was more than one of my kids school fees for one year.


Posted By: Homer
Date Posted: October 13 2014 at 4:35am
I dont think the new ownes would mind me posting these.

Sorry to hi-jack your thread Max.


Posted By: Eggy
Date Posted: October 13 2014 at 4:35am
I still cringe at the recollection of some of the crimes I committed against various BSAs/ Nortons/Matchless/AJSs back in the 60s. At that time they were worthless junk and could be found dumped in hedge bottoms or given away to scrap dealers, forward on 50 years and see what old Brit bikes sell for nowCry

-------------
Devout Yorkshireman


Posted By: Homer
Date Posted: October 13 2014 at 4:51am
This was my best with the PH mag.





Posted By: Homer
Date Posted: October 13 2014 at 4:53am
And the mag.






Posted By: Jon287
Date Posted: October 13 2014 at 5:39am
I agree that anyone is entitled to modify their rifle for their needs as they see fit. But, it is still a sad thing to see one that modified to the point where it can never be restored. I have a 1943 matching numbers Long Branch #4 Mk1* that "Bubba" cut the bayonet lugs and front sight base off of. It's set in a synthetic stock and has a scope. It is a he!! of a deer rifle but, it will never be what it was.Stern Smile


-------------
Now is the time for all good men to come to the aid of their planet!!


Posted By: Shamu
Date Posted: October 13 2014 at 7:25am
Horses for courses in my opinion. I do have some restrictions s to what I'll do with a clear conscience.

I won't permanently modify anything that can't be returned to bog stock, & I'll keep the parts to do so.

I won't modify something legitimately rare. One of a few million made is fair game though.

I usually only modify to resurrect function, even within those limitations.

Its not everyone's choice & I've been pilloried & punished for it on some sites with a narrow viewpoint, but hey it's the internet anyone can be anything & there are still multiple ways to skin a cat.


-------------
Don't shoot till you see the whites of their thighs. (Unofficial motto of the Royal Air Force)


Posted By: Jon287
Date Posted: October 13 2014 at 9:36am
Another good example.....
http://www.armslist.com/posts/3501378/oklahoma-rifles-for-sale--1944-lee-enfield-no-4-mk1---t----" rel="nofollow - http://www.armslist.com/posts/3501378/oklahoma-rifles-for-sale--1944-lee-enfield-no-4-mk1---t----


-------------
Now is the time for all good men to come to the aid of their planet!!


Posted By: W.R.Buchanan
Date Posted: October 13 2014 at 10:37am
Eggy:  I had a  1966 Matchless Typhoon 600cc single when I was 18 years old in 1968.  Paid $350 for it and sold it a year later for $500.  The bike was complete and the only mod was a disgusting Green metal flake paint job and a Bates Megaphone.
 
I painted it black and replaced the Bates mega phone with a proper megaphone that would literally blow your ears out. The stock pipe was long gone. 
 
Got numerous noise tickets and would just reinstall the Bates pipe and get it signed off, and then go back to the real megaphone. I was well known by the cops in my town.
 
That bike would easily bring $15K here now.  The Typhoons were a little more rare than the G50's over here but neither one was something you saw every day.   Most ended up at Ascot on the half mile track racing BSA Gold Stars. Or in the desert racing Hare and Hound.  They were highly modified by that time. By 1970 both were obsolete as the tuners had figured out how to make Triumph 500 Twins go faster, and 650 TR6's ruled the desert.  The Jap bikes took over by 1972 and the English bikes faded into history.
 
Randy


-------------
It's not how well you do what you know how to do,,, It's how well you do what you DON'T know how to do.


Posted By: Eggy
Date Posted: October 13 2014 at 11:37am
Originally posted by Jon287 Jon287 wrote:

Another good example.....
http://www.armslist.com/posts/3501378/oklahoma-rifles-for-sale--1944-lee-enfield-no-4-mk1---t----" rel="nofollow - http://www.armslist.com/posts/3501378/oklahoma-rifles-for-sale--1944-lee-enfield-no-4-mk1---t----
$1500 Ermm


-------------
Devout Yorkshireman


Posted By: Eggy
Date Posted: October 13 2014 at 11:52am
Originally posted by W.R.Buchanan W.R.Buchanan wrote:

Eggy:  I had a  1966 Matchless Typhoon 600cc single when I was 18 years old in 1968.  Paid $350 for it and sold it a year later for $500.  The bike was complete and the only mod was a disgusting Green metal flake paint job and a Bates Megaphone.
 
I painted it black and replaced the Bates mega phone with a proper megaphone that would literally blow your ears out. The stock pipe was long gone. 
 
Got numerous noise tickets and would just reinstall the Bates pipe and get it signed off, and then go back to the real megaphone. I was well known by the cops in my town.
 
That bike would easily bring $15K here now.  The Typhoons were a little more rare than the G50's over here but neither one was something you saw every day.   Most ended up at Ascot on the half mile track racing BSA Gold Stars. Or in the desert racing Hare and Hound.  They were highly modified by that time. By 1970 both were obsolete as the tuners had figured out how to make Triumph 500 Twins go faster, and 650 TR6's ruled the desert.  The Jap bikes took over by 1972 and the English bikes faded into history.
 
Randy
Happy days Randy, just loved the " Matchbox and Ajay " singles, as a 16 year old with £250 to buy my first real bike I passed on a Matchless G80CS (also metalflake green) and a Velocette Thruxton both priced out of reach at £325 but bought a 1967 Bonneville for £225. Many years later I found in a chicken shed a 1957 Matchless G3L CS ex factory short stroke scrambler restored it and sold it on for £1400 ( paid £90 for it) now worth 14k. Crystal ball would have been nice 50 years ago Wink

-------------
Devout Yorkshireman


Posted By: Jon287
Date Posted: October 13 2014 at 11:55am
Originally posted by Eggy Eggy wrote:

Originally posted by Jon287 Jon287 wrote:

Another good example.....
http://www.armslist.com/posts/3501378/oklahoma-rifles-for-sale--1944-lee-enfield-no-4-mk1---t----" rel="nofollow - http://www.armslist.com/posts/3501378/oklahoma-rifles-for-sale--1944-lee-enfield-no-4-mk1---t----
$1500 Ermm

But, look what they sell for unmolested!!!
http://www.gunbroker.com/Auction/ViewItem.aspx?Item=444863832" rel="nofollow - http://www.gunbroker.com/Auction/ViewItem.aspx?Item=444863832


-------------
Now is the time for all good men to come to the aid of their planet!!


Posted By: Bear43
Date Posted: October 17 2014 at 6:40pm
Max, I have to say that your posting on that honestly made me physically ill.... I hate such destruction of history. I guess that's why I pick up these orphans that other dingbats have stripped down.... It's an attempt to right a wrong. I just wish people could be convinced to stop it. I see the same thing with vehicles. I also work on old trucks (utes down under) and we see the same happen with them. People part out running vehicles simply because their pocketbooks get bigger from the parts than from selling the truck. Sad stuff! Cry



Print Page | Close Window

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 12.07 - https://www.webwizforums.com
Copyright ©2001-2024 Web Wiz Ltd. - https://www.webwiz.net